Incoming Archbishop of Canterbury Faces Scrutiny Over Abuse Case Handling

In This Article
HIGHLIGHTS
- Dame Sarah Mullally, the incoming Archbishop of Canterbury, faces a complaint over her handling of an abuse allegation.
- The complaint, initially made in 2020, was not followed up due to administrative errors at Lambeth Palace.
- The complainant, known as N, claims the mishandling of his case severely impacted his mental health.
- Church authorities have apologized and are taking steps to address the complaint through the appropriate statutory process.
- Stephen Cottrell, the Archbishop of York, will decide the next steps regarding the complaint.
The Church of England is currently reviewing a complaint against Dame Sarah Mullally, the incoming Archbishop of Canterbury, regarding her handling of an abuse allegation. This development comes as Mullally prepares to assume her new role following the resignation of Justin Welby, who stepped down amid a safeguarding scandal.
Background and Allegations
Dame Sarah Mullally, who has served as the Bishop of London since 2018, is accused of improperly managing a complaint against a priest in London. The alleged victim, referred to as N, reported the abuse to the Diocese of London, claiming it began in 2014. N alleges that Mullally breached church disciplinary protocols by contacting the accused priest directly about the allegations.
Administrative Oversight
The complaint against Mullally was initially filed in 2020 but was not pursued due to administrative errors and assumptions about the complainant's wishes at Lambeth Palace. Church authorities have since acknowledged these oversights, with a spokesperson stating, "Due to administrative errors and an incorrect assumption about the individual’s wishes, the complaint was not taken forward or appropriately followed up."
Response and Next Steps
In response to the situation, Mullally expressed regret over the handling of the complaint, stating, "The alleged victim has been let down." She emphasized the need for strengthened processes to ensure timely and satisfactory responses to complaints. Church officials have written to N, outlining the next steps in addressing the complaint.
Role of the Archbishop of York
The Archbishop of York, Stephen Cottrell, who faced similar scrutiny last year, is now tasked with determining the appropriate course of action. Cottrell has the authority to dismiss the complaint, impose sanctions, or escalate it to a church tribunal for further investigation.
WHAT THIS MIGHT MEAN
The handling of this complaint could have significant implications for the Church of England's reputation, particularly in light of recent safeguarding scandals. If the complaint is escalated, it may lead to further scrutiny of the Church's processes and potentially result in reforms aimed at preventing similar oversights in the future. Experts suggest that the Church must prioritize transparency and accountability to restore public trust. As Dame Sarah Mullally steps into her new role, her response to this challenge will likely set the tone for her tenure as Archbishop of Canterbury.
Related Articles

Church of England Faces Scrutiny Over Dismissal of Abuse Complaint Against Incoming Archbishop

Archbishop of York Cleared of Misconduct in Controversial Abuse Case

Historic Appointment: Dame Sarah Mullally Becomes First Female Archbishop of Canterbury

New Archbishop of Westminster Calls for Church Accountability and Social Justice

Church of England Halts Same-Sex Blessing Ceremonies Amid Ongoing Debate

Historic Appointment: Cherry Vann Becomes First Female Archbishop of Wales
Incoming Archbishop of Canterbury Faces Scrutiny Over Abuse Case Handling

In This Article
Ethan Brooks| Published HIGHLIGHTS
- Dame Sarah Mullally, the incoming Archbishop of Canterbury, faces a complaint over her handling of an abuse allegation.
- The complaint, initially made in 2020, was not followed up due to administrative errors at Lambeth Palace.
- The complainant, known as N, claims the mishandling of his case severely impacted his mental health.
- Church authorities have apologized and are taking steps to address the complaint through the appropriate statutory process.
- Stephen Cottrell, the Archbishop of York, will decide the next steps regarding the complaint.
The Church of England is currently reviewing a complaint against Dame Sarah Mullally, the incoming Archbishop of Canterbury, regarding her handling of an abuse allegation. This development comes as Mullally prepares to assume her new role following the resignation of Justin Welby, who stepped down amid a safeguarding scandal.
Background and Allegations
Dame Sarah Mullally, who has served as the Bishop of London since 2018, is accused of improperly managing a complaint against a priest in London. The alleged victim, referred to as N, reported the abuse to the Diocese of London, claiming it began in 2014. N alleges that Mullally breached church disciplinary protocols by contacting the accused priest directly about the allegations.
Administrative Oversight
The complaint against Mullally was initially filed in 2020 but was not pursued due to administrative errors and assumptions about the complainant's wishes at Lambeth Palace. Church authorities have since acknowledged these oversights, with a spokesperson stating, "Due to administrative errors and an incorrect assumption about the individual’s wishes, the complaint was not taken forward or appropriately followed up."
Response and Next Steps
In response to the situation, Mullally expressed regret over the handling of the complaint, stating, "The alleged victim has been let down." She emphasized the need for strengthened processes to ensure timely and satisfactory responses to complaints. Church officials have written to N, outlining the next steps in addressing the complaint.
Role of the Archbishop of York
The Archbishop of York, Stephen Cottrell, who faced similar scrutiny last year, is now tasked with determining the appropriate course of action. Cottrell has the authority to dismiss the complaint, impose sanctions, or escalate it to a church tribunal for further investigation.
WHAT THIS MIGHT MEAN
The handling of this complaint could have significant implications for the Church of England's reputation, particularly in light of recent safeguarding scandals. If the complaint is escalated, it may lead to further scrutiny of the Church's processes and potentially result in reforms aimed at preventing similar oversights in the future. Experts suggest that the Church must prioritize transparency and accountability to restore public trust. As Dame Sarah Mullally steps into her new role, her response to this challenge will likely set the tone for her tenure as Archbishop of Canterbury.
Related Articles

Church of England Faces Scrutiny Over Dismissal of Abuse Complaint Against Incoming Archbishop

Archbishop of York Cleared of Misconduct in Controversial Abuse Case

Historic Appointment: Dame Sarah Mullally Becomes First Female Archbishop of Canterbury

New Archbishop of Westminster Calls for Church Accountability and Social Justice

Church of England Halts Same-Sex Blessing Ceremonies Amid Ongoing Debate

Historic Appointment: Cherry Vann Becomes First Female Archbishop of Wales
