The Unbiased Post Logo
Thursday 09/04/2026

National Maternity Review Highlights Persistent Failings Amid Police Investigation Concerns

Woman at crossroads with maternity care symbols and documents
Ethan BrooksEthan Brooks

In This Article

HIGHLIGHTS

  • A national review led by Baroness Valerie Amos excludes Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital Trust due to an ongoing police investigation.
  • The interim report reveals persistent issues in maternity care, with poor and minority mothers facing worse outcomes.
  • A Care Quality Commission survey found that 18% of women felt their concerns were ignored during childbirth.
  • The survey highlighted both improvements and ongoing challenges in NHS maternity services, including communication and support.
  • Health Secretary Wes Streeting emphasizes the need for urgent improvements following the report's findings.

The state of maternity care in England remains a pressing issue, as highlighted by a recent interim report from a national review led by Baroness Valerie Amos. The review, which aims to address systemic failings in maternity services, notably excludes the Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital Trust (SaTH) due to an ongoing police investigation. This decision has drawn criticism from bereaved families, but Baroness Amos defended it, citing potential conflicts with police timelines and evidence handling.

Ongoing Challenges in Maternity Care

The interim report paints a concerning picture of maternity care across England, revealing that families continue to face inadequate care and empathy. Particularly affected are poor and minority mothers, who experience worse outcomes. Baroness Amos expressed shock at the repeated trauma endured by women and families, underscoring the need for urgent reforms.

Survey Reveals Ignored Concerns

Complementing the review, a Care Quality Commission (CQC) survey of nearly 17,000 women found that 18% felt their concerns were not taken seriously during childbirth. Additionally, 15% reported not receiving relevant advice or support when contacting a midwife at the onset of labor. These findings highlight the critical need for improved communication and support within NHS maternity services.

Mixed Progress in Maternity Services

Despite these challenges, the survey also noted some improvements. A significant 89% of respondents reported being spoken to in an understandable manner, and the same percentage were offered mental health support during pregnancy. However, the persistence of issues such as inadequate staffing and lack of empathy remains troubling.

Calls for Urgent Action

Health Secretary Wes Streeting, who initiated the review to drive improvements, emphasized the need for swift action to address the systemic failures identified. Clea Harmer, CEO of the baby loss charity Sands, echoed this sentiment, stressing that listening to parents is crucial for saving lives.

WHAT THIS MIGHT MEAN

The exclusion of the Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital Trust from the national review due to the police investigation could delay comprehensive reforms in maternity care. As the police inquiry progresses, it may uncover further insights into systemic issues, potentially influencing future policy changes. Experts suggest that the findings from both the review and the CQC survey could lead to increased pressure on NHS trusts to prioritize maternity services and implement recommended improvements swiftly. The ongoing scrutiny may also prompt a reevaluation of resource allocation and training for healthcare professionals to ensure that all women receive the care and attention they deserve during childbirth.